Which is better Ugg clic short or Ugg clic tall?

I wanted to know which one was better, because I heard both of these boots come with different problems. I heard that when you tuck in your skinny jeans in the clic short, the jeans come out after a while. Also, for the clic tall I have seen many people that have their boots sagging. Please help me with this, because I bought the clic short, and people are telling me they aren't as warm as the clic tall!